Mularkey > Whisenhunt : Part 1

How much better is Mularkey compared to Whisenhunt?

whiz mulark

Mike Mularkey took over Ken Whisenhunt’s head coaching duties and gained approval in his first game as interim Head Coach.NFL: Tennessee Titans at New Orleans Saints

Mularkey helped orchestrate an overtime win against the New Orleans Saints. Some Titans fans prematurely jumped the gun and hypothesized that Whisenhunt must’ve been the problem.

mari saint

Near the end of the season, praise for Mularkey had faded. Tennessee would scrape by Jacksonville in Week 13 of the 2015 season, 42-39. That would be their only win following their victory over the Saints. Fans were impatient and Mularkey’s seemed to be in the hot seat.

With changes to the front office, many wondered and some even hoped Mularkey would get the boot. Names like Josh McDaniels floated around, along with others. GM Jon Robinson decided to stay the course and choose consistency over a coaching carousel.

In hindsight, it turns out his seat wasn’t as hot as some projected. He remains the teams head coach and will head into his 2nd year as full-time head coach. Mularkey heads into his 3rd season with the team having the most talented roster the team has seen in some time. But what could Whisenhunt have done with a more talented group?

The Numbers

Comparing Whisenhunt to Mularkey may be irrelevant at this point since Whisenhunt will never be on the Titans sideline in a coaching capacity ever again. However, this post will focus on how the two compared during their time in Tennessee.

Mularkey has coached two more regular season Titan games than Whisenhunt, but game by game statistics can show how the two stack up against each other.

By the Quarter Totals

Tennessee Titans head coach Mike Mularkey. PHOTO BY MATTHEW MAXEY


Mularkey has 8 more wins and 6 less losses compared to Whisenhunt. In looking at box score – a quarter by quarter breakdown – Mularkey outscored his predecessor by 50 in the 1st, 61 in the 2nd, and 99 in the 4th. Whiz edged out Mularkey in the 3rd by 26.

Offensively, the numbers show Mularkey is statistically better. However, it is important to note that the talent on the 2016 roster exceeded that of the 2015 roster.

Defensively, Whisenhunt held opponents to fewer points by 26 in the 1st and 23 in the 2nd. Mularkey held opponents to 3 fewer in the 3rd and 1 in the 4th.

Division and Coaching Mariota

Tennessee Titans v Tampa Bay Buccaneers

In terms of the division, Mularkey coached two more games against division opponents. He recorded two more  wins. However, both coaches have losing records in the division. If Mularkey wants to prove he is the better option over Whisenhunt, a winning record against the division is a must.

Jacksonville Jaguars v Tennessee TitansIn reference to the talent, Whisenhunt had Mariota for 5 games. Mariota was unavailable against Atlanta and Houston following injury suffered following the Oliver Vernon hit in Miami. The Dolphins game would be Whisenhunt’s last opportunity to coach Mariota.

Mariota’s production under Whisenhunt is charted below.

Whiz Mariota stats

Now, here is what Mariota’s stats looked like in the first 5 games coached by Mularkey.

Mularkey Mariota Stats


Measuring how Mariota fared with the same roster for 5 games: he threw 3 more passes, gained 34 more yards, 1 more touchdown, 1 less interception, was sacked 8 less times, had 2 less fumbles, and 1 more win.

Not drastic differences, but small improvements none the less. In 5 games, Mularkey + Mariota were more productive than Whisenhunt+Mariota.

This will be Part 1 in this series. The next posts will be more in depth look at the quarter-by-quarter comparison between Mularkey and Whisenhunt.

***All credit for the photographs featured above goes to the respective author(s). I do not claim any credit for the photographs featured above. Statistics referenced from Statistical charts created by this author***



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s